The case in a few lines
In 2007, Upper Deck, then the game's distributor in North America, had about 600,000 copies of nine cards printed in China, without Konami's authorization. According to a Konami filing in the lawsuit, Upper Deck's president admitted both points in a deposition.2 Some of them reached American stores in boxes with three authentic booster packs and the cards on display.4 In December 2009, a U.S. court held two Upper Deck companies liable for trademark counterfeiting, and the case ended in a settlement in early 2010.13
For collectors, the lawsuit matters less than what stayed on the market: nine cards with the wrong hologram, still in circulation, and nine replacement cards that almost nobody knows about.
The nine cards
The list mixes two highly sought Ultimate Rares with cards from McDonald's Promotional Cards 2. All of them imitate 1st Edition or Limited Edition printings.6
| Card | Original copied | Printing imitated | K version |
|---|---|---|---|
| Elemental HERO Flame Wingman | TLM-EN035 | Ultimate, 1st | TLM-EN035K |
| Elemental HERO Aqua Neos | POTD-EN031 | Ultimate, 1st | POTD-EN031K |
| Destiny HERO - Dreadmaster | EOJ-EN004 | Ultra, 1st | EOJ-EN004K |
| Water Dragon | EEN-EN015 | Super, 1st | EEN-EN015K |
| Elemental HERO Electrum | MDP2-EN001 | Rare, Ltd | MDP2-EN001K |
| Elemental HERO Mudballman | MDP2-EN002 | Rare, Ltd | MDP2-EN002K |
| The Flute of Summoning Kuriboh | MDP2-EN004 | Rare, Ltd | MDP2-EN004K |
| Mist Body | MDP2-EN005 | Rare, Ltd | MDP2-EN005K |
| White-Horned Dragon | MDP2-EN006 | Rare, Ltd | MDP2-EN006K |
A silver hologram where it should be gold
1st and Ltd
Unl and OCGThe TCG rule is simple. 1st Edition and Limited Edition have a gold hologram. Unlimited has a silver one.7 The nine cards carry the 1st or Ltd mark with a silver hologram, and that's the first sign.269
On a card from 2005 or 2006, the color of one little hologram can separate an Ultimate Rare from a counterfeit.
This is where people get fooled. Someone looking for a Flame Wingman Ultimate 1st sees the right rarity, edition mark and code. Plenty of people never even check the hologram color, and the difference in value is big. In November 2026, PriceCharting listed about $75 for an ungraded authentic copy and about $2,900 for a PSA 10.11 We found no reliable price for the silver hologram version. According to a 2022 account, PSA wasn't grading these cards.10
The hologram alone doesn't settle it. Collectors report legitimate errors with silver instead of gold on Ltd Ultra Rares from Invasion of Chaos: Special Edition and on European 1st Edition Ultimate Rares from Shadow of Infinity, with no Konami documentation.10 That's why checking takes several steps.
- The list. The card and the code have to be in the table above.
- The eye on the hologram. On the seven cards that aren't Ultimate, the 2022 account describes the eye rotated 90 degrees counterclockwise.10
- The texture. On the two Ultimates, the surface has only straight lines.10
- Font and shine. Konami cited the hologram, fonts, paper feel and shine as differences.2 The font tends to come out thicker on the non-Ultimates. Ink color varies between sources, so compare against a copy you trust.610
The letter K: the collection almost nobody knows
TLM-EN035K
EEN-EN015K
EOJ-EN004K
POTD-EN031K
MDP2-EN001K
MDP2-EN002K
MDP2-EN004K
MDP2-EN005K
MDP2-EN006KHere's the most interesting part of the story. There are nine cards with the same artwork and a K tacked onto the end of the code, like TLM-EN035K. All of them are Rare, Unlimited, with a silver hologram, and nothing about them tries to imitate an Ultimate.6
According to Yugipedia, Konami sent them as replacements to people who complained to customer support about the card, with no announcement and for a short time. Few copies went out.6 "K Series" and "UDE Redemption Cards" are community nicknames, and TCGplayer catalogs them as Redemption Replacement.8 They were never sold in booster packs, which explains why so many people spend their whole time in the hobby without seeing one. Some were, at the time, the only Rare version of the card, as with Flame Wingman.6
As a collection, it's a rare target: just nine cards, a closed list, and the hard part is finding them rather than paying for them. In November 2026, TCGplayer market prices ranged from about $10 for Aqua Neos to $75 for Flame Wingman, with few listings.8 Mist Body and The Flute of Summoning Kuriboh look like the hardest: between them there was a single listing, and a 2022 account even claimed they didn't exist in this version. The Yugipedia gallery and the TCGplayer entries indicate they do.6810
Open questions
- No one has published how many K cards exist, when the replacement program ran or what the K stands for.
- The replacement program is described only by Yugipedia. Konami's statements don't mention it, and the idea of an "apology" has no documentation.36
- Nobody knows how many silver hologram cards are still in circulation. More than a third were reportedly recovered before sale.5
Comments
none yetCreate your free account to comment and save the cards from this article.
Get the next stories
One collection story every two weeks, straight to your inbox. Just reading, no ads.
You can unsubscribe anytime, in one click. See our Privacy Policy.