A detail the scan doesn't show
The security hologram in the bottom right corner has rows of eyes and the text YU-GI-OH!, which you can see in almost any light. The hologram's color and what it says about the edition are already covered in our piece on the Upper Deck cards, and its debut is in our guide to the OCG series. This is about something else: at some point, the hologram gained very small stars, spread in a regular pattern, that only show up at very specific angles.1
Collector accounts mention two to four stars visible at a time, and three in a 2020 video.67 Yugipedia describes a pattern across the whole hologram. Both can be true if only some stars catch the light at each tilt, but that's our guess.
Silver hologramThe rule of thumb, and where it comes from
An old layout with stars in the hologram means a late reprint.
That sentence is our rule, inferred from what the sources say. Konami never published it, and we found no official statement about the stars. Forum collectors say almost the same thing: stars in the hologram mean a reprint, and no stars doesn't prove the card is an original.45
The second half matters as much as the first. English LOB came back in 2010 in Legendary Collection, the one with the binder, and those cards have no stars. According to Yugipedia, they are hard to tell apart from the ones that came out in the 2003 tins.24 So the star only works one way: it flags the reprint when it shows up and says nothing when it's missing. For the other LOB tests, like the card text, see our set guide.
The best case: Korean LOB
The set came out in Korea in December 2003 and returned in March 2011.2 In September 2019, it came back again, and that's where the rule earns its keep. The boxes from 2019 on kept the 2011 date. The cards came in the layout of the time, with the old text, without the errata. From the outside, they look old. Yugipedia says they all have stars in the hologram.2
LOB-K125
LOB-K125 Reprint
LOB-K000
LOB-K000 ReprintYugipedia's own table of identifiers helps separate the runs by the code on the bottom of the box:2
| Code on the box | Year | What Yugipedia notes |
|---|---|---|
19KRE | 2019 | All Secret Rares are Prismatic |
20KRE | 2020 | No note |
21KRE | 2021 | Cards with darker ink |
22KRE | 2022 | Cards with darker ink |
The 2019 pack has a black tip instead of a blue one and a 2011 date on the back.2 The page text says printing went on until at least 2021, and the table already lists 2022 boxes. The ink difference is the second sign, with a caveat: it only separates the new runs from each other.
Korean packLOB didn't come back alone. Yugipedia says the dark ink also shows up in Legacy of Darkness, Pharaonic Guardian and Dark Crisis, reissued around the same time, and Tactical Evolution returned in Korean on February 18, 2020.29 One detail is missing: the stars are only written up for LOB. In those other sets they're what you'd expect to find, and nobody has documented them.
LOD-KR100
PGD-KR000
DCR-KR105
TAEV-KR006When the stars started: the sources don't agree
Here the sources clash, and we couldn't resolve it. The most cited date is 2017, but none of the sources below shows where it got its date.
| When | Product | Who says so | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| October 2010 | Legendary Collection, binder | Yugipedia and Elite Fourum: still no stars24 | The firmest point |
| November 2013 | Legendary Collection: Gameboard Edition | Collector on Elite Fourum, in 20214 | Account |
| 2014 | Legendary Collection reprints | 2020 video, with three stars6 | Account |
| "2014 or 2017" | No product | Another collector on the same forum, unsure4 | Uncertain account |
| Around 2017 | Code of the Duelist, August | Yugipedia, hologram page, and Misprint18 | Encyclopedia, no source cited |
| August 2018 | Shadows in Valhalla | A store guide (Misprint), read only as a search snippet8 | Weak |
Yugipedia's LOB page complicates the math. It says the 2010 cards have no stars, unlike the later Legendary Collections, without saying which ones.2 If that applies to Legendary Collection 2, 3 and 4, from 2011 to 2013, the stars predate 2017 and the hologram page is off by years.
But the sentence can be read another way. The same page says LOB came back in the Gameboard Edition in November 2013 and was reprinted in 2014 and 2017, with the year on the front of the pack.23 The "later" ones may be just those. In that case, the stars could have started with the 2017 run, and the two pages would stop clashing. One collector says the 2014 cards are the same as the 2017 ones, without saying anything about 2013.5
There's one more loose lead. In February 2018, a Pojo user reported stars on Dark Crisis and Invasion of Chaos cards bought from a seller.7 If the cards were legitimate, the August 2018 start falls apart. We only read the snippet, not the replies, and it doesn't say whether the cards were legitimate.
What the doubt changes in practice
Less than it seems. No source puts the stars before 2011, and the 2010 cards don't have them. So, by our inference, a card from a classic set with stars was printed after the 2010 Legendary Collection, whatever the answer to the table.
The doubt matters for cards from the in-between period. Without the date, you can't say whether a 2012 card with no stars is normal, or use the star to tell the 2013 Gameboard apart from the 2017 one. The card in hand has the answer: just tilt 1st Edition copies of Legendary Collection 2, 3 and 4 under strong light. 1st Edition matters because an Unlimited copy may have come from a later run. That check hasn't been done yet.
LCGX-EN001
LCYW-EN001
LCJW-EN001Open questions
- The first product with stars. We found no Konami statement and no photo comparison between sets.
- The reason. Yugipedia calls the stars an anti-counterfeiting technique, without citing a document.2
- The OCG. Code of the Duelist came out in Japan in April 2017 and in Korea in July, before the TCG.10 The hologram page only gives the TCG date, and we don't know whether the change reached every region at the same time.
- Counterfeits. No source says whether they copy the stars. A star only proves what the rule says, and never authenticity.
- The other Korean sets. There are no accounts of stars in Legacy of Darkness, Pharaonic Guardian, Dark Crisis or Tactical Evolution.
- Price. We found no sales that separate 2019 Korean LOB from 2011, so we don't give a value.
Comments
none yetCreate your free account to comment and save the cards from this article.
Get the next stories
One collection story every two weeks, straight to your inbox. Just reading, no ads.
You can unsubscribe anytime, in one click. See our Privacy Policy.